Talk:Guidelines/@comment-71.197.215.26-20150222042650/@comment-24087318-20150222050842

Hahaha no. You're completely misreading things. The Dust video, as well as elaboration during various production videos says that Dust, in its most basic form, starts as crystals based off of four primal elements, Fire, Water, Wind and Lightning. Any hybrid or advanced Dust type (eg. Gravity) is stated to be made through a combination, either artificially made or naturally formed, of the primary types to create the new effect. Things like Ice dust possibly being made from a combination of Wind and Water, as an example. Beyond the other canon examples, and sort of fan-made Dust element has to go through a reviewing process, and one of said processes is that it has to be explained what exactly it's base dust elements are, and preferably how prevalent it is naturally, or if it's only made artificially.

Think of a Complex Dust element (Gravity, Ice, etc) as a Hydrocarbon, and the basic Dust types as Carbon, Oxygen, Hydrogen. Different combinations of them creates vastly different end products. That's how Dust is explained in the World of Remnant videos.

You have, frankly, no idea what you're talking about. Speculative evidence is one thing, but *fact* is required. And the facts state in no way that Dust has to be a "natural element" with its effects. They can infer all they want, but until such time as it's proven, that not be how it is. Especially with Fanon rules and guidelines.