Talk:Siegfried Drachentöter/@comment-24052959-20150515071215/@comment-4109747-20150517065047

@ Cryo, Could you of structured that better?

Starting with your opening paragraph "Siegfired graduated at the top of his class so he can't be that weak. Secondly, 7.5 isn't really that high, in fact 5 is too low. He is supposed to be an A star student and is good at everything but not the best"

7.5 is high, though I will agree a 5 is also too low, who about 6 or 6.5 average?

" Naruto is op in his universe, have you watch Naruto Shipppuden, he is 17 but is stonger than most of the teachers,students,jonin,chunin and hokages. Naruto trained hard? He depended on his nine-tailed fox most of the time. Ichigo is 17 but is also super stong at the last episode of the anime."

Your starting out with where they end up, not starting with where they began. In the beginning they are not OP; they eventually attain that Level through work, experiences, and trials, your character is OP from going through nothing, but "working hard" at a entry school. He's a student, you can only be brought so far by school, let alone a basic training academy like Calm, the real training and teachings would of come from Hope.

Now for the arguments aimed at me or have no clear target:

"11. That is stupid, you can be a critque but you can be polite which you clearly are not. You said that my character is generic but your reasons are pathetic. From time to time, you kept saying that my character is generic but is that you only argument, if so that is pathetic. He is a knight that is capable of range attacks, kills evil, a bit of an anti-hero and uses a shield and sword. How is that generic, not many characters in anime do that."

I've been polite in not attacking you, which clearly you've attacked me several times. Yes, I've said your character is generic 1 time and that being his appearance. It's red armor, basic knight gear, nothing special at all, no details, as to what it's made of, how it was made, who made it, does it resist anything other then basic damage, Is there anything that separates from other knights in appearance, No! As for your other points here Ranged attacks are almost a must in RWBY, so can't use that as an excuse; Kills evil, that's part of the job; Bit of an Anti-hero, not really since he is already on the good side; Uses a shield and sword, a lot of knights use those. You don't apparently watch a lot of anime or know of a lot of anime.

"4.My characters have weakness however small or big does not matter. The last I checked having weaknesses does not constitute a better character." and "5.Again pointing out how OP is my character is that the only other arguement you have. Again my character is not immortal nor invincible he still can die if you cut his head or stab his heart."

Yes it does matter, its about balance and being relatable. For how much good there is there should be roughly equal bad. Your character has almost no weakness and what weakness he does has little/no effect on anything. And yes cutting off your head is going to kill you, but "Siegfried has an extremely large amount of aura so much so that he would be able to regenerate his entire arm even if it was cut off" a stab to the heart may not be a kill, also how many people can "...take explosions that would easily decimate an entire building" Compared to Juane who "...has a lot of [Aura]" he only been shown to recover from a small cut and burses, nothing to the extent of losing an arm or surviving a explosion of that magnitude.

"7,8,11 from my previous argument still holds strong as you have not rebutted it properly."

Those have very little to do with your character and are just attacks against me, rather then actual defenses to help your character's case.

What kind of training did he go through in that school in order to become that strong, fast, intelligent, that young?

Just for fun "2.You can find a few characters like mine but I doubt you will ever find 20 characters that is exactly the same or is similar and well known to people."

I'll just name a few anime(s), rather then the Specific character in the anime, "Akame ga Kill", "Seven Deadly Sins", "Log Horizon", "Sword Art Online", ".Hach//", "Berserk", "Guin Saga", "Good Witch of the West", and "Dragon Age: Dawn of the Seeker".