Board Thread:News and Events/@comment-17970636-20140601223053/@comment-26388029-20140602031305

Cutting right to the chase:

Review:

Hmm. Tanner, to be honest, has less development (if any) than Julian has. Julian, with his hard backstory and stoic personality, has undergone much change to get to his character. Although, I have to note that living in the desert can be hard at times (Send down the rain~). I just feel that Julian's personality is much more thought out and deep than Tanner could ever be. Julian wins this part.

Fight:

First of all, Tanner has no semblance, which is really unfortunate, as Julian immediately has an advantage. Also, I must point out his weakness section.

Firstly, he has trouble pulling out his weapon. That's not going to bode well, as it'll give Julian an immediate opening.

Secondly, he also has trouble fighting alone. I'm just gonna let you people process my previous sentence.

...

No shit he's fighting alone!

But I must give Tanner points where he deserves it. He's an expert marksman, and can shoot dynamite out of the air (given RWBY characters can do that in their universe, and anime). Why? Because dynamite, as I said in my last review with Julian, are bound to be slower than bullets.

Alas, though, Tanner's fighting style is also very predictable. Julian will see this and take advantage of it.

Sorry for my ruthless logic, but Julian takes my vote.