Talk:Guidelines/@comment-35253515-20180128165119/@comment-13593058-20180128180101

This has been brought up a multitude of times and it can work. Fortunately it's not as bad as what we usually compare it to, namely Qrow's Bad Luck Semblance.

Charm or attractiveness, while subjective, is technically measureable and perceivable from person to person so it should be fine; it would be better if you could somehow make it interesting instead of an abritrary stat boost Semblance.

The issue Reviewers have with Qrow's Bad Luck Semblance is that it's completely arbitrary in the way that it works, how do you count something as "bad luck"? And what's the scale of such an ability? So keep Qrow in mind when you think of Semblances like that.