Board Thread:News and Events/@comment-17970636-20140509015753/@comment-17970636-20140510052520

Alright, this for me, was a hard decision. I've seen both these characters for a while, and this battle was a hard one for me, but my analysys went like so.

Edwin's semblance plus his form of attacking does give him an edge in a sense that he can effectively defend. Liadan may be able to strategize, however, Edwin being a stretegist as well can counter her and so they reach a stalemate there.

The two also have their forms of ranged attacks. Liadan having Briar Rose, and Edwin with his dust shells. Their experience also makes it a close match.

I'll get to the point, so Liadan has defensive AND offensive glyphs. However, the limitations set the semblance at a bit of disadvantage to Edwin's "pride" kind of defense. Assuming Edwin's pride is as big as a trumpet player's, she'll have a hard time taking him down.

She may be faster than him, but his melee attacks sebsequently could wear her defensive glyphs down, even with her ranged attacks, the tank will not be deterred!

Thus, my vote goes for Edwin.