User blog comment:Derrmann/Why multi-function requirement is a bad idea./@comment-24143795-20140127002159/@comment-24143795-20140127035745

I agree the "weapon with personality" thing shouldn't be a rule, but more of a understanding amongst the fanon. That would probably be something that any user, reviewer or not, could comment saying "The weapons kind of bland, how is it different from someone elses [insert type of weapon here]" without it being a deal breaker for an accepted, or not accepted OC.

I agree with what your saying regarding labels like "swordsmen". If someone is trained with a sword, technically that does make them a swordsmen. I think I'm just being paranoid that some people may use the labels of "swordsman" or "mage" as a shortcut when describing their OCs, which, as someone who has spent hours just flipping through OC pages and reading them, I would be really depressed to see.