Talk:Jaescon Palderas/@comment-24416658-20160322013919/@comment-26441125-20160326001900

So I've edited out every grammar and spelling mistake I could find, and removed the comparsion to Yang (her having high scores was an inference on my part, and I apologize for the confusion.) I clarified that he does not possess any of Pyrrha's fame or name recognition. But I have a question about your rejection of his semblance. I used the word "transformation" several times in the description, and I have removed every use of the term. But Jace has been previously accepted under the old guidelines, before the re-review, and I rechecked the guidelines on semblances after the re-review. It says, as a direct copy paste, " This means they were still off the books when Jace was first accepted, and there's been no movement on that front during Volume 3. I understand and agree with the Fanon's determination to not open the can of worms presented by Qrow's possible transformation until we get hard evidence, but this is very dissimilar from that. Jace isn't a werewolf, he's not full body shapeshifting, and his semblance has clearly defined limits and uses. We've seen characters manifest fire and electricity in canon from their Semblances, and I don't see a character manifesting another much less flashy element as any kind of breach from that. I would just like clarification on why he was accepted under the same set of rules that you cited as grounds for rejection. Please note, I don't mean this with any kind of disrespect, and I hope I'm doing this as respectfully as possible. I have no malice towards you personally because of your honest evaluation, which I am grateful for, as it helped me improve Jace's page. But his Semblance was one of the first things I determined about his character, and it's central to his character's theme and overall foundation, and I don't want to have to drastically alter it over a possible misunderstanding. I will wait to resubmit him or edit him further until I hear back from you about it. Thanks for your time.
 * Transformation semblances are remaining off the books until canonical evidence is given.