Thread:Cat-Soup64/@comment-27984457-20170112172812/@comment-27743663-20170112205411

That's what I meant, but like I said, there's no evidence indicated Dust can do that. As far as we've seen, it's the crystallization of elements, not a magical healing substance. Either way it's a moot point to bring up.

You don't have to scientifically explain them, unless you want to. You just have tto explain. Saying X happens because X doesn't make much sense if you don't give how it happens in the first place. Bad luck isn't a confirmed semblance either, for all we know Qrow could have just been talking metaphorically in bias towards his failures.

An additional note, while I didn't mention it in the review since I'd figure it's a given as it's in the guidelines her semblance does additionally need some limits. Is it passive and does it activate automatically in any of those scenarios? Is it active and she has to manually activate it first? Also she can't keep it up forever, so it needs a cost or a maximum limit, or both. No semblance has been shown to last indefinitely.