Talk:Northkolrwolfe Vincent Valentine/@comment-933831-20141231045051/@comment-8182065-20150101055742

"(a) also my character is 15 meaning he was born after the trend and he was born outside the kingdoms away from all the trends and (b) was born into a roaming village that stuck to the outside so no way to know what was going on in vale besides rumors from passers by so what gives you the right to declare that all our characters must be named after color or must be affiliated with color and (c) my characters middle name is valentine and he has a red shirt he wears i forgot to mention which i will ad in later and (d) there fore i declare your rule unfair and unjust towards others and discriminatory towards other patrons hard efforts to add to your wonderful site that we enjoy so much so im going to be like the parents of remnant and let out a cry for freedom and change"

A. Actually your character is listed as 16. Unfortunately, that's the youngest a reviewer will accept in terms of age as Ruby was a special case; Ozpin had picked her personally to attend his school, and he doesn't exactly have the time to scout the talents of every 15 year old.

B. The tradition is a Remnant thing, not just a Vale thing, so everyone in the whole world follows this tradition (every character, it's not exactly easily noted at first, except Ozpin follows this trend).

C. It would have to be first name (ex. Red Smith) or first and last name (ex. Red Blueford or Cyril Ian= Cerulean). Middle names don't count unfortunately, mainly because it's doesn't exactly follow the naming rule (and is honestly a lazy way to try and fit the reference IMO).

D. You can always submit your OC for a re-review, always. A rejection isn't permanent. This isn't Tsu's rule, or any other member of staff's; the Color rule was created by Monty himself, and delivered onto the fans for the sake of their OCs fitting in well with RWBY. It's not discriminatory in any way, a lot of users on site who came into this issue have complied with the rule upon learning of its existence (that goes for new users and the older ones who had to change names/look for references to fit the rule).

Also Maki is right on the Glynda thing. Also there's no rule stating a character has to wear the color they reference on the fanon or given to us by Monty.