Talk:Tyde Carnelian/@comment-24087318-20140830032632

Character is great all-around, but there are a few issues.

His Semblance, in short, seems redundant given the existance of Fire dust, and what we now know Dust is capable of. A person with a couple of fire crystals worth of it could do exactly what his Semblance does, but better, longer and to a greater effect.

Having the characters color name for the Naming Conventions be a nickname instead of his actual name is a bit of a cop-out too. Why not just make it Tyde Carnelian if you want that?

In addition, Aura isn't discovered as far as we know, it has to be activated intentionally. It's Semblances that are discovered over time, or through battle.

Due to these above points, Rejected.

~RWBY Fanon Administration Team~